6-10 Competition

In the last chapter, we talked about the importance of diversification. A key to that lesson is that you should strive to have stocks across multiple industries, but also try to have more than one stock in any single industry. When you make your investments, keep in mind that companies in the same industry are competitors – the actions of one company will directly impact the profitability of the others they compete against.

How To Compare The Competition

When looking between several stocks in the same industry, especially an industry you might not be familiar with, you can use the tools we have covered so far to make a wise investing decision between the alternatives.

These are some of the key factors to look out for:

Investing in Innovation

The last lesson focused on New and Improved processes and products – as an investor, you really want companies that are not afraid to innovate, because successful innovation means growth. Take a look at the company’s press releases and Investor Relations for hints on how much each competitor is investing in innovation.

You can also use the company’s financial statements as a “cheat sheet” – the Income Statement usually includes a specific line-item for Research and Development as an operating expense. Companies that invest more of their total operating budget on R&D are focusing more of their efforts on innovation. Be careful with this method though – just because they invest in innovation does not mean the investment will pay off. You will need to use your judgement to guess at which company’s recent product or process announcements is more likely to pay off in the long-term.

PE Ratios

We also talked about PE ratios earlier in this chapter. When looking at stocks across the entire market, PE ratios can give little guidance. But within a single industry, PE ratios are more comparable, and gives you a direct look at how much the company is earning compared to the price of the stock. Companies within the same industry with a higher PE ratio are generally more attractive investments.

Those accountancy ratios we talked about earlier really comes into play when comparing competition within the same industry. This lets you pull away the “marketing fluff” around product announcements and press releases to see which company is actually looking more profitable.

Industry Trends and Price Points

By now, you are probably thinking of some companies that you might want to invest in, and how to evaluate them by how much they’re innovating, and comparing their performance ratios against the competition to decide which stock to buy and which to sell.

But remember that your goal is diversification on both fronts – and the stock market is not always a zero-sum game. “Industry Trends” are when an entire industry is poised for growth, and (as a whole) that market grows. Think of a housing boom – when many people are buying houses, companies who build construction equipment, mix cement, develop property, sell lumber, and sell glass for windows will all start to do well. This means that if you are trying to decide between Caterpillar (CAT) and Deer & Company (DE) as your investment in construction equipment, you might be missing the big picture – buying a bit of both would keep your portfolio more diversified and help capture more of the industry trend.

Then, over time as the housing boom starts to cool off, you can evaluate both companies and decide which position you might want to start selling off in order to increase your position in a different industry. When the “Industry Trend” is growth, there is not necessarily a “winner” or “loser” to worry about.

Mark's Tip
Mark

There are a few companies that operate in industries without competitors. Intuitive Surgical (ISRG) developed the first surgical robot that performs minimally invasive surgery and reduced hospital stays from 4 days to 1 day in some instances. That stock went from $20 to $325 from 2004 to 2007. FedEx (FDX) initially had the monopoly on overnight package delivery—it took UPS and the United Postal Service a few years to catch up. Crocs (CROX) shoes were the craze for at least a year until other shoe companies started copying them.